Goal
By the end you can say what kind of thing each of these names is: a kernel, a complete system, a set of tools, a standard, or a company's product. People use these names as if they were all the same kind of thing, and they are not.
The idea in plain words
Names in this area sit on different levels, and mixing the levels causes most of the confusion.
A kernel is the core that manages the hardware, as the earlier guide on the operating system explained. A complete system is a kernel plus all the tools around it, so you can sit down and use it. A set of tools is a collection of commands, such as ls and sed, that can run on top of a kernel. A standard is a written description of how things should behave, so that different systems can agree. A product is something a company sells or ships.
One name can mean two levels at once. People say Linux for the kernel, and also for a whole system built around it. This guide says which one it means each time.
The point to keep is this: the tools that you type, such as grep, are separate from the kernel under them. The kernel and the tools can come from different places.
A picture
Read the picture from the top down. Each column is one way to build a system. Every column has a kernel at the bottom and tools above it, but the pieces come from different families.
macOS Linux with GNU tools a small device
----------- ------------------- ----------------
graphical layers GNU tools BusyBox (one tiny
(ls, sed, grep, ...) program with
BSD tools ---------------------- tiny versions of
(ls, sed, ...) Linux kernel many tools)
----------- ----------------
Darwin kernel Linux kernel
Diagram: three columns, each a way to build a system. The first is macOS, with graphical layers on top, then BSD tools such as ls and sed, then the Darwin kernel at the bottom. The second is Linux with GNU tools, with the GNU tools such as ls, sed and grep on top and the Linux kernel at the bottom. The third is a small device, with BusyBox on top, a single tiny program holding small versions of many tools, and the Linux kernel at the bottom.
Another way to see it
Think of a car. The kernel is the engine. The complete system is the whole car. The tools are the dashboard controls you use every day. A standard is the road code that every car must respect. And a product is a particular brand of car that a company sells.
| Name | What kind of thing it is | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Unix | The original system, and a family | AT&T Bell Labs, then many |
| POSIX | A standard | Ratified by IEEE and ISO/IEC |
| BSD | Releases, and a family of systems | UC Berkeley |
| FreeBSD | A complete system | The FreeBSD Project |
| Darwin | The open core of macOS | Apple |
| macOS | A product that adds to Darwin's core | Apple |
| GNU | A project, and its set of tools | Richard Stallman and others |
| Linux | A kernel | Linus Torvalds and others |
| BusyBox | One program that holds many tools | Maintained by Denys Vlasenko |
The last column names who started each one. For BusyBox it names the maintainer listed on its own site. Many people have worked on each. Apple's description of Darwin and macOS that this guide relies on is archived documentation from when the system was called OS X, so check Apple's current pages for today's details.
Walk through it
Here is how to work out what a computer is running, one step at a time.
- Ask for the kernel's name with
uname -s. A Mac saysDarwin. A Linux system saysLinux. This tells you about the bottom layer only. - If the answer is
Darwin, the system is macOS, or Apple's open-source Darwin on its own. Its command line tools come from the BSD side of the family, on top of the Darwin kernel. - If the answer is
Linux, you know the kernel but not the tools. The tools could be the GNU ones, or BusyBox, or something else. - To learn which tools you have, ask a tool. Run
sed --version. In this project's tests, a GNUsed(version 4.9) printed a line that begansed (GNU sed). The BusyBoxsed(version 1.37.0) printedThis is not GNU sed version 4.0. Thesedon macOS rejected the option with an error. That is three different answers to one question. - Because the answer comes from asking the tool and not from guessing, this project's
explaincommand works the same way. It looks at the program itself before it picks the right documentation.
The kernel's name never settles the question of which tools you have. That is why Linux alone does not tell you what sed will do.
Try it
These commands only look at things. Each one works on its own.
Ask for the kernel's name and use it to decide what to print. The test command checks the text and sets the exit status that && and || use, as in the guide on exit codes. You will see one of the two sentences, depending on your computer. The backslash at the end of a line tells the shell that the command goes on:
test "$(uname -s)" = Darwin \
&& echo "kernel: Darwin" \
|| echo "kernel: not Darwin"
Ask sed for its version, and keep only the first line. A GNU sed names itself. The BusyBox one says that it is not GNU sed. On macOS you will see an error about an illegal option, and a usage line, because that sed has no such option. The answer depends on your system, so there is no fixed output:
sed --version | head -n 1
Common confusions
- Linux is a complete operating system. The name Linux belongs to the kernel. A complete system adds tools. The GNU Project calls a complete system made of its tools and that kernel GNU/Linux.
- macOS is Unix-based, so it is the same as Linux. They are separate families. macOS includes the BSD command-line environment, and much of the technology in its core derives from FreeBSD. Linux is a separate kernel written from scratch.
- BusyBox is a version of Linux. It is not. It is a single small program that holds tiny versions of many common Unix tools, usually with fewer options than the GNU ones. It runs on top of a kernel, often Linux.
- POSIX is a program. It is a standard: a written description. Systems aim to follow it, and Linux aims towards POSIX and Single UNIX Specification compliance.
- GNU is only a license. GNU is a project that set out to write a complete Unix-compatible system, and it produced many of the tools you use.
Check yourself
- Is Linux a kernel or a complete system? Answer: the name Linux belongs to a kernel. A complete system also needs tools.
- What is Darwin? Answer: Apple's open core of macOS, with a kernel and the BSD command-line environment.
- Is POSIX a program or a standard? Answer: a standard.
- What is BusyBox? Answer: one small program that holds tiny versions of many tools.
Where next
The next guide, explain learn same-command-many-versions, puts this to use: it shows why one command name, such as sed, can mean different programs with different options.
To see commands from the different families side by side, look at explain sed and explain cat.
References
Original explanations, with sources for further reading. Words you do not know are in the glossary.
- https://www.kernel.org/linux.html
- https://www.gnu.org/gnu/gnu-history.html
- https://docs.freebsd.org/en/books/handbook/introduction/
- https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Darwin/Conceptual/KernelProgramming/Architecture/Architecture.html
- https://busybox.net/about.html
- https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man7/standards.7.html